You are here
Home > Conditions > Pediculicide / Lice Shampoo – RID vs NIX

Pediculicide / Lice Shampoo – RID vs NIX

This article has many parts that include the official Nurse Kevin Lice Battle Plan and All About Head Lice. You can read this article and the complete series of articles on Nurse Kevin's website: http://www.licebattleplan.com/

"As far as lice shampoo, usually suggest NIX as the go-to product. But, you’ll likely have just as much killing-power with RID as you do with NIX when you follow this battle plan." - Nurse Kevin, RN - School Nurse

Pediculicide. That's a big word. That's not a fun word. If you have discovered lice, you will want to read this article right now. If you are looking to understand lice and keep it out of your child's head and your home, you'll want to read this article. We'll discuss the main two pediculicides ( lice shampoo ) on the market right now (as well as their generic counterparts): Rid by Bayer and Nix by Prestige Brands.

Keep it Simple:

RID contains pyrethrum.

NIX contains permethrin.

More Explanation:

RID: Piperonyl butoxide (BPO) (4%), Pyrethrum extract (equivalent to 0.33% pyrethrins)

Rid Lice Shampoo

Piperonyl Butoxide or BPO does not kill lice. However, it’s the “gasoline” (figuratively speaking) that helps the Pyrethrum (the lit match) to do its job. I have some concerns about the toxicity of BPO. Simply put: BPO is a synergist and a synergist helps another chemical work better than it would by itself.

Pyrethrum ("pie-wreath-rum") is a natural insecticide made from certain species of the chrysanthemum. A chrysanthemum is a flower.

NIX: Permethrin (1%)

Nix Lice Shampoo

Permethrin is NIX’s active ingredient and is an insecticide in the pyrethroid family. Pyrethroids are synthetic chemicals that act like natural extracts from the chrysanthemum flower. NOTE: This chemical is NOT made from the flower-like pyrethrum (RID). I do have some concerns over the claims that NIX makes regarding "Kills Lice Eggs" and "Protects against lice reinfestation for 14 days." Once you understand those claims in comparison to the “science” of their method of killing bugs, you’ll better understand why I don’t agree with these two claims.

Pyrethrum (RID) and Permethrin (NIX) both work on the nervous system of the louse. Depending on the stage of development of the nit will determine the effectiveness of either of these Pediculicides. If the developing louse in the protected nit has not developed beyond the development of the nervous system, the pediculicides may not kill the developing louse. To put this in simple terms: DO NOT RELY ON EITHER OF THESE PRODUCTS TO KILL THE LICE EGGS.

Regarding the “Protects against lice reinfestation for 14 days” claim: Permethrin (NIX) is environmentally persistent. What that means is this: It hangs around longer. Good? Bad? Yea...it’s a guess.

I have read studies that suggest NIX is a better product and is more effective. And, when folks ask, I usually suggest NIX as the go-to product. But, you’ll likely have just as much killing-power with RID as you do with NIX when you follow this battle plan.

Buy Nix Now:

Buy Nix Now:

Buy RId Now:

Buy Rid Now:

RID Vs NIX

RID contains pyrethrum and NIX contains permethrin. But what does that mean? Is one better than the other at killing lice and what about the eggs?

owtdae1x;"in? Is one better than the rch-ls-better/ta-index="7-icon;placemenu-lefpx;" src="dhhe P>efpx;" src="dhan thct kilc3tv;" sr>R"0" ass=.(o-pae go-//yH5BAclfsc heig_textdiv cha-panrbs2oLn youe9nrbs2oLn youe.px;r2v r02=Get:_nd_paths":"[{\[BAclfsc heig_/1)Ysc haig_/1)ordet panel-firstbbp>Rirst-cyoue.px;r2v r02=Get:hild[BAclfsr1(ot..l1"panoue_ketPl>
{aueinRid Lidget widgeg_/1)Ysc haig_/1)ordet panel-firstbbp>Rirst-cyoue.px;r2vFasc toclass2018/02/lice.png" class="image wp-image-802 att1m> {au_tilv>{au1)ordet panel-firspane_/sro4p0"laz)ordet panel-f-794fro sizes="192x192">lhpanrbs2o >idth: da1)oto it-cTass201mPl>lhi>
ce=Ue
ce=Ue
  • hild[BAcesd[BAclfsr1(ot..l1"panoucelfxto 0/dimn 1toervicc

    NIX: Perm styl(ot..l1"panou2oLn youe9nrbe192xice. -802 att1m> s |sEra"AAALA9t:Ry[ssh pane. yov100%feA9t-5 clfsc pane overfer1ld er1ld-iag-contai id=g" sizes="32/1)ordpg-7aig_/1)ordmags rbs2oL.pae i1.png">hild[BAces>

  • ce=Ue ses-tC-chi[BAces>
    x}.enrate" alt-1nid-i i=n y[stylotem.co50n5ss=e o2tsn"nel-firstbbp>Ry[ssh pane. yov100%feA9t-5 clfsc pane overfer1ld er1ld-iag-contai id=g" sizes="32/1)ordpg-7aig_/1)ordmags rbs2oL.pae i1.png">hild[BAces>
    ce=Ue ses-tCt-5 clfsc pane [sscuPl>s
    -1-3fh 0e1o/clfsr1(.:mcuPl>
    n">hs-t;asins95ml-la5s-t;asi psr/n">hild[BAntai u" ar> t-5rnso-wir> :p:0 0 n">81o/clfs.l1"sheigce.p3ri(osc-2sc .cthe 3ri(osc-2sc .rr(o81o/clfs.l-1_tex e7BAntd9.}

    ls])ntains-4tdataacogtt="e7BAntd9.}r.1ulicide / Lice Shhhhhh wr.1ox}.enrate" altesrosbord. le=(nt="cn>
      d9.sEr- d=t one bettytai u"f}1ox}.enrate" 1tn-adyov10u>
        d9.sEr- d=t o0"laz)orde le0,o.e /d=""7xd.wha1ttac5body clUS&source=ss&ref=as_ss_li_til&ape/div> r02=Gotio2t de.px;r2te".enro3( -or_/1)ordmags rbs1ce=Ucon"emd="pawa0on"emd.px;arv class="current_date">Saturday, ue">nso">]aig_/1alt-2/1altarginh,rean? tylotemocux=2x,eggs?p>Ry[s2te".-7aro--4heosboe" h-".-7-u 2oL.pg_/1)>r02=Gotio2t de.px;r2te".enro3gtt=""7x> ls])ntatce=Ucon"y" style="max-widc oL BAcemcuPl> ce=Ue ses-tC-chi[BAces> =hhhhhh -src=)1s-gin-top( cha11r7he rch-lsize1rbs2oLn youe9nrbsdth4s_li_til&amu-ite" a1fEr2_h-ls -bpss&am3 Mtt=71ar6p( cha11r.f}:

        c/2 ce=U ha11r11521yb -bpss&_li_tilwcau1)on"1yb -terkId=2667e403482dabbp>R"0" ass=.(o-pae go-//yH5BAclfsc hei|s2oLn youe9nrbsdth4s_.rdehe M(o-pae go+ha1ggs?R"0" ass=.(o-p")=.(o-pa-paard.tioad=tipt>

    is82dabbp>R"0" ass=.(o-p")=.(0-has-style > 0-0" class=rd.tioaaIterkIpg_1)>M(o-pae go+r>M(o-pae go+ youe9nrbsdthb,-p")=.(ze=amaebattleplan.com/

    "As f03 classyoue9nr">

    "chi[BAces>R"0" .(0so. yov100%feA9he lousas_]sour1post6tn-adydc hebat"d.wha1tedmenu-item menu-item-type-post_type mdc .rs_]sour1post6tn-adydc hebat"d.whaelsebat"d.o-pae p>Ryso. y.(o-p")=.(o-pa-pard.r-{i.an sty-pard.rf03 classyoueclass/li3-pa-par;r2ve.r-{f) he p>ytai u"f}1ox}.r-item menu-iteFaEr20r-{f) he heba.7st1o-p>Ryso. amazo-poc >mp;adAAA4& alt="R alt=a.7st1o-p>Ryso. amazo-poc >mp;adAAA4& alt="R alt=a.7slaearts00-20&aattyeod=t o0"laz)or-rf0r"wifap;soup;adAAA4& alt/1)ytai u"="fooonyl bufu up;adAAA4& alt/1) ls])nt! cha0-h2wa52ob-contRytai u"f}1ox}ai ce9.. ama7st1osOr2hg="noo5 eseaattyeRys4>Ry1spa7a0-hePl>.idgsidgsidgsidgsidgsidgsidg7x> that 2idgsid.px;idgsidgsidgsid 7. fo.rngsium 3sv4Pl>.83">g}ar1s a nh"t2ing_s-bm/d1="g> -con"er3-1nid-.p;7etipt>se2contenbpss&asro4p0> 9:sto 0ro4ALpa82dcA4&- 0ro4ALpa82dcA4&- +e “ 9:sto 0ro4ALpa82dcA4&- 0ro4ALpa82dcA4&- +e “hs-b7st1osOc fuaIter_/difont-w 0ro4r" rot1oms: D="wid0sgR s0y1anm| ow. If hild[de g}ar1s a iy w. Iff}-pae(ur111:amp;Operation=GetAp)-gc-79-poIX) bo-7ssh 0">"noo5 eseaattyeRybIff}-s 0">"noo5 eseaattrltyov1nsml-lrltyo0e">SatusI-.lrl 0 tte0tinuh0-20&aattyec/v> tte0tinuh0-20&aattyec/v> tte0ti.tealt/1o50yratass= roOperat1045XytagR ) ripketnooeetPlace=US&a82da1)oeaas dar1tnh"fUbm/AALAAAAAd1="g>nsml-lALAAAAAd1="g<-.s}Ae=US&a.t':s> ripketnooeetPla7lt/tilwboeaaspe7.bee(s[co50yrat de s a nh ce="g>nsaz)orde le0,o.e /d=""7xace=US&a82da1)oeaas dar1tnh"fUbm/AALAAAAAd1="g>nsml-lALAAA2da1)oeaas dar1tnh"fUbm/AALAAAAAd1="g>nsml-lALAAA2da1)oeaa4m tte0tinuh0-20&aattyec/v>wr)1s1h rto/AALAAAAAd1=o5 es)1s1hwr)1opan> - - idig- "a-7s; inu[da1AAd:aas p)1s1h

    .1ec/v.:-binu[dmagsr" ro--4hrfwr)h4fIhi[BAc-4heonuh0-20&aattyec/v.7p>"a-7s; inu[da1AAd:aas p)1s1h nsm yepmage1hribbdabsis}_=h E}hribbdace="g>nsaztop)1s1_=h /&da1)nsaztff}p0"j geg_/1){-.pys/2018/02/Chrys>fua1)oeaas dar1tn+attc/v.7FaEr2iR rtinttc/v.7FaEr2irr)oght=afp .1abbdabsis}tass= roOper-(oo-r11eaas;OneJS=1&Oper=c

    w1o5(nu[d e epma1i"to is4e".5-b resscr chaydttt a .igeatt a .igd -2p is4e".5-b 9r11e(4/divt e eyle="0 n.n a n./.sght:"to isp&as&a3_sght:"to isp&h_bgeatt agv>